Book Recs Based Off Of Broadway Musicals!

Ohhh yeah. This is it, kids.

It’s time to combine two of my favorite things: books and Broadway musical soundtracks.

I love listening to Broadway musicals (I’ve never gotten the chance to watch one, on tour or in NYC) and the thing I really like about their soundtracks is how cohesive a lot of them are. You hear the same motifs over and over, the same melodies blending together, and you can understand the musical’s story from listening to the soundtrack.

Some soundtracks you can understand the whole story without hearing the in-between acting, while other soundtracks you might need a little help from Wikipedia or Genius Lyrics.

But either way, I love Broadway musicals. I also love books, because although they tell stories in a different way, they still have a lot of similarities–themes throughout, etc. .

So, today I’ll be recommending books based on Broadway musicals, but this can work both ways! If you haven’t heard the soundtrack–listen to it! You might just find a new favorite song (or a brand new passion).

Without further ado, here they are!

Hamilton + Alex & Eliza by Melissa de la Cruz

My entire Broadway obsession started with, of course, Hamilton.

It is definitely very un-Broadway–it’s got a lot of hip hop and rap in it–but it’s still SO SO AMAZING.

And my book rec that matches is none other than Melissa de la Cruz’s Alex and Eliza! Besides both of these sharing that wonderful falling in love between the legendary Alexander Hamilton and Eliza Schuyler (see: Helpless), they also excel in showing the eighteenth century off really nicely.

I found the historical context in both the musical and de la Cruz’ book to be wonderful, and it’s like you’re transported in the smack dab middle of the American Revolution (see: Yorktown (The World Turned Upside Down)).

Alex and Eliza was definitely surprising for me because I wasn’t expecting to love it as much as I did when I already knew so much about their relationship. If you’re a diehard Hamilton fan, it doesn’t hurt to check this book out!

note: Alex and Eliza is not affiliated with Hamilton or any commissioned work.

Dear Evan Hansen + The Window by Amelia Brunskill & Dear Evan Hansen: The Novel by Val Emmich et al.

I have to include the very obvious Dear Evan Hansen: The Novel by Val Emmich et al. because who isn’t excited to read the wonderful musical Dear Evan Hansen in book format?!

Seriously, this musical would make such an amazing YA novel, especially with all the themes on mental health and coming of age. So Dear Evan Hansen: The Novel was a had-to-include for me, just because.

But also, there’s this one song in Dear Evan Hansen called Waving through the Window (so good!!!) that always reminds me of Amelia Brunskill’s mystery novel, The Window. They both have that sort of sad-ish sort of mood and that reaching, you’re-drowning-in-life sort of feel.

The Window really examines how a girl deals with the murder of her twin sister, and it’s not only a mystery novel, but it also works with the main character’s growth in the novel, which is largely characterized by that feeling I described that you hear in Waving through the Window.

So yeah, listen & read to all of these awesome pieces of popular culture!!!

Anastasia + Heart of Iron by Ashley Poston

Is this one not obvious?

Because besides Heart of Iron being an Anastasia retelling, there’s just a lot of similar feels in both the Anastasia Broadway musical and the novel.

I mean, think of all the betrayal and class differences within Anastasia, like how Anastasia’s the long lost princess and Dmitri is just some commoner boy and Gleb’s whole spiel. And then think about the betrayal and class differences in Heart of Iron.

Yes, please nod along with me as we realize there’s MORE SIMILARITIES BESIDES JUST THE LONG LOST PRINCESS PREMISE. Hot damn, Ashley Poston.

So yeah. Plus, songs like Still are great mood music for Heart of Iron. Honestly this entire soundtrack is awesome so like, go listen to it and also read Heart of Iron if you haven’t already?

Into the Woods + Starry Eyes by Jenn Bennett

This is probably my favorite comparison of this entire list.

Into the Woods, if you’ve seen the movie that’s based off of the Broadway musical, talks a lot about how different things seem in the woods–how people act differently and everything appears different and more magical and the woods kind of exist outside of reality.

And Starry Eyes by Jenn Bennett is about two teens who have a past together getting lost in the woods when going glamping (glamour camping) with their friends. And guess what? Things are different in the woods.

In It Takes Two of Us from the musical, a scene where the baker and his wife are talking, the baker’s wife says “You’re different in the woods,” and this phrase could not be any more related to Starry Eyes.

Things are different in the woods, both in Jenn Bennett’s Starry Eyes and in the musical Into the Woods. I totally recommend both, if not just for the swoony romance and a witch yelling “Greens, greens!”

Frozen + Girls Made of Snow and Glass by Melissa Bashardoust

Alright, I admit that I haven’t actually listened to the Frozen Broadway soundtrack yet.

But I do have friends who have listened to it (it’s on my TBL I swear) and I’ve obviously watched the movie, so I have a pretty good basis to make this comparison.

The stepmother in Girls Made of Snow and Glass is basically Elsa. Basically. Besides both having mad icy powers, there’s also that just pain that they both have to carry on their shoulders to live up to certain expectations, and it’s the main reason why I made this comparison. Mina just goes through so much in this novel, and I feel like her struggle really relates to Elsa’s.

Also, these both have top notch atmospheric similarities with the snow and the glass and the chilly things. Such a good book though, and I definitely recommend you check this out! Also, people have said the Broadway soundtrack is even better than the movie’s, so 😉

Cats + Grim Lovelies by Megan Shepherd and Girls of Paper and Fire by Natasha Ngan

Ok, you’re probably like “Ew, Vicky–you like Cats?” and I PROMISE I’M NOT A CATS PERSON; CATS IS WEIRD OK?

Cats really is weird and I watched a filmed production of it once when I was younger and now I have never had any sort of inkling to think about this musical again. (Also, this is my preemptive “I DON’T UNDERSTAND CATS & DON’T REALLY SUGGEST YOU LISTEN TO IT” warning.)

But, Grim Lovelies and Girls of Paper and Fire both remind me of Cats, but they’re like, better, okay?

Cats reminds me of people dressed up like cats for no apparent reason (remember, I watched it when I was like 10 so I really didn’t get it). And Grim Lovelies and Girls of Paper and Fire both feature animal/demon people, which I find very cool.

So, if you’re looking for something with animal/demon fantasy people (sort of like the chimera in Daughter of Smoke and Bone), I definitely recommend you check both of these books out! The jury’s still out on Cats, though.

They’re like the actors and actresses in Cats, but less scarring.

(For all I know Cats could be wonderful so if you’ve listened to it lmk)

Wicked + Dorothy Must Die by Danielle Paige

Of course, Wicked has just gotta be on this list somewhere, right?

Wicked is a little mainstream for me (you: don’t you listen to Hamilton, Vicky? me: …yes.) and it was so Popular (hehe, catch my reference?) that I just don’t listen to it that much.


In Dorothy Must Die, Dorothy is obviously the bad one. And in Wicked, Elphaba is the heroine, although she has her bad patches from time to time. Both of these novels twist the original story in an inventive and creative way, but still keep the loveable parts of the novel.

I definitely recommend you listen to Wicked if you haven’t already (it’s a great start to getting into Broadway) and also Dorothy Must Die for it’s dark nature and twisted storyline.

Mean Girls + People Like Us by Dana Mele

Eep! Mean Girls on Broadway is my latest obsession, and it has not been disappointing in the 2449398390 times I’ve listened to it!

It’s a lot like the movie, just with sassier characters and better music and acting. Also, singing and dancing and cake (which is a line from Revenge Party). And People Like Us by Dana Mele is basically a Sapphic Mean Girls boarding school murder mystery.

Can a get a woot woot?

If you’re looking for some mean girls who are a little confused about vests (see: Fearless) and life, then definitely check out both of these for awesome music and mean girls and boarding school murders. People Like Us will not disappoint with its twisty nature, just like Regina’s plots with Aaron.

much love, vicky

What Broadway musicals that I didn’t list here would you recommend + matching books? Let me know which ones you love in the comments below!


24 thoughts on “Book Recs Based Off Of Broadway Musicals!

    1. Ahhh I hope you get the chance to watch something on Broadway one day! And I feel like Starry Eyes and Into the Woods just really work together, don’t you think? They both play on the same concept which is mindblowing.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. lol Wicked is such a classic though! and ANASTASIA IS SO GREAT although I had no idea there was someone named gleb in it, which I only learned was a major character due to the Wikipedia page yesterday. oops.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. i’m still so confused over this Gleb person lolol the movie is the only reason why I understand some of this musical ngl

        Liked by 1 person

  1. This is such a great idea – musicals and books are two of my absolute favourite things. I’ve only been to two musicals so far, though: Mamma Mia! in NYC and American Idiot in Toronto. Really looking forward to reading Alex & Eliza!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes! If you ever have the chance, I totally recommend you listen to these! And Alex & Eliza was awesome–I hope you enjoy reading!


  2. This post was so cool! I definitely just added a ton of books on Goodreads. I don’t know what it is about Mamma Mia! but it is my all time favorite musical. I love that Sophie doesn’t need a man to know who she is, I love that its set in Greece, and I love that someone took the songs from only one band and crafted an entire story around it. I know your not a book/musical matching machine lol but me know if you have any book recommendations for Mamma Mia!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you and oooh, I know so may people love that one! I will definitely think of a book rec for that–the closest I’d say is Love & Luck by Jenna Evans Welch? The MC has the same independence that you’re talking about and the book is more about her own personal growth than romance (I honestly wanted more romance ahaha) and it’s also set in Ireland! (Which is not Greece, but still European)

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Thank you for the recommendation! It sounds like it has a Mamma Mia! vibe so I’ll have to check it out. I’ve already read two books this month with guys named Rowan, so I might have to wait a little until I can keep my Rowans straight lol

        Liked by 1 person

  3. THIS IS TOTALLY WORTH HOLDING MY PANTS UP WEDGIE LEVEL FOR! i read this as soon as i saw it this morning but i had to go to school but i’m definitely gonna check out these books! i’ve only listened to dear evan hansen and into the woods (i watched the movie heh) fully, though. (my favorite song is “if i could tell her” it’s so cute) and then i’ve yet to listen to anastasia fully but my fave song is definitely “in a crowd of thousands”.

    i wish i knew what books would match these musicals but if you haven’t listened to them i highly recommend hairspray and legally blonde!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. OH MY GOSH IF I COULD TELL HER IS ADORABLE and everything about Anastasia makes me sentimental :’)

      Maybe you just need bigger pants 😉

      I will also definitely try and listen to both of them (I have the legally blonde movie ahaha) and I watched hairspray a long time ago but I remember loving it! will get back to you with recs for those <333

      Liked by 1 person

      1. It changes so often, but the first musical I really fell in love with was Wicked. It is also the only musical I’ve seen on Broadway so I’m definitely partial. I’ve been enjoying Heathers a lot lately though!

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.